EN/FR
Bladi.net

French Renovation Firm Fined €157,000 After Morocco Call Center Linked to 282 Violations

A French company specializing in energy-efficiency renovations has lost its appeal against a €157,000 fine. At the heart of the case: a call center in Morocco, 304 consumer complaints and invoices that enabled investigators to trace the telemarketing operations.

By Farid Laamoudi
French Renovation Firm Fined €157,000 After Morocco Call Center Linked to 282 Violations

The case dates back to an inspection launched in December 2022 into Eco Smart France, a company based in Villeurbanne that sells insulation products and solar panels. Fraud enforcement officers had identified a phone number that had received 304 complaints on Bloctel, France’s platform for opting out of commercial telemarketing.

The investigation led officers to Call R, a call center platform in Morocco. Eco Smart France bought sales leads from the center, in a sector where telephone canvassing to sell energy-efficiency renovation work was prohibited.

The French company disputed its responsibility. It said that the people contacted had never indicated they had been called on its behalf. It also argued that the number belonged to a call center working for several clients. The company therefore rejected having the 304 complaints attributed to it.

Invoices that led investigators to Morocco

The inspection established that the line used by Call R was assigned to Vdistry-Infinity, another company with which Eco Smart France had business dealings. Investigators then examined the company’s invoices to determine precisely which operations could be attributed to it.

Of the 304 complaints recorded, 282 violations were ultimately attributed to Eco Smart France. In its ruling of October 6, 2026, the Lyon Administrative Court found that the investigators’ findings were sufficiently substantiated. The company had provided no evidence to support its argument that the calls could have concerned other clients.

This part of the case alone accounts for a €100,000 fine. The total penalty, however, came to €157,000, as inspectors had identified several other irregularities in the company’s sales practices.

Eco Smart France had used the official MaPrimeRénov’ visual without authorization on seven pages of its website. This practice earned it an additional €35,000 penalty, calculated at €5,000 per page. Investigators had also found irregularities in quotes, terms and conditions of sale, and information provided to consumers.

On Bladi.net : Calls from Morocco: up to 375,000 euros in fines per call without consent

The company had asked for the penalty imposed in August 2024 to be overturned or, failing that, reduced to €11,400. The court rejected its arguments, including those concerning the cumulative fines and their amount.

The judges also upheld the requirement to publish the penalty. Eco Smart France was required to publish it on its website and social media accounts. Publication on the websites of the fraud enforcement agency and the state services in the Rhône département had also been ordered for a period of thirty days.