Former Moroccan PM Benkirane Sparks Debate on Ramadan Fasting and Alcohol Sales

Thus Benkirane, who asked the PJD youth to distinguish between what is law and what is religion, gave an example that he considers convincing on this issue, namely the sale of alcohol to Muslims. A sale that would not, according to Benkirane in his robe of scholar, be prohibited. The reasons he cites is that the sale of alcohol to Muslims has (always?) existed in Muslim countries.

He indeed declared, according to Telquel: "Throughout Islamic history, alcohol is ubiquitous, despite the fact that it is considered haram. We know that the prophet did not appreciate alcohol drinkers. In Morocco, it was Lyautey during the French protectorate who banned its sale to Moroccans. He certainly had his own reasons."

Benkirane also spoke about "those who break their fast" during Ramadan: "With regard to our religion, if someone wants to break their fast during Ramadan, it’s their problem. The prohibition was established by the State, which prohibits anything that could disturb public order."

Note that according to Article 222 of the Penal Code, one to six months in prison (and a fine of 200 to 500 dirhams) is the penalty incurred by anyone "notoriously known for his belonging to the Muslim religion, who ostensibly breaks the fast in a public place during the time of Ramadan, without a reason admitted by this religion."

It should also be noted that a 14-year-old girl in Ouazzane has just been beaten by a school bus driver because she ate during Ramadan, even though she had a valid reason.