EN/FR
Bladi.net

French Court Rejects Homeowner’s €43,929 Claim After Fire

A man living in Fès who owns a house in France received more than 266,000 euros from his insurer after a fire. Believing the payout was insufficient, he asked a French court for nearly 44,000 euros more.

By Laila M.
French Court Rejects Homeowner’s €43,929 Claim After Fire

On May 31, 2019, a fire ravaged a house in Tournay, in the Hautes-Pyrénées. Its owner had taken out home insurance with Amaguiz, whose commitments were taken over by Groupama Rhône-Alpes Auvergne. The property was then rented out for 1,290 euros a month.

On Bladi.net : They Claim 8 259 Euros After Their Car Caught Fire in Morocco, but Their Own Video Betrays Them

The insurer offered compensation of 269,391.72 euros, which the owner accepted. Of that amount, 266,417.72 euros was actually paid to him. But settling the claim led to a dispute. In December 2022, the man sued his insurer, seeking an additional 43,929.48 euros.

The largest part of the claim concerns lost rent. The owner is seeking 30,190 euros for the period during which he was unable to rent out the property. Groupama had already paid him 16,250 euros for this in 2019 and 2020. The policy caps compensation at one year’s rent, a clause the court found sufficiently clear to reject his claim.

Insurer disputes additional repair work

Another point of disagreement was fees related to the reconstruction. The owner is seeking a further 3,786.50 euros in project management fees. He submitted an invoice for 11,234 euros, corresponding to work estimated at more than 226,000 euros. The judges, however, found that he had not shown he actually paid these fees beyond the 6,682.85 euros already covered by the insurer.

He is also seeking 9,952.98 euros for additional work. Among the disputed expenses is a fourth roof window, billed at 2,469.87 euros, which he says was omitted from the original estimate. Without that estimate, the court could not establish that its replacement had indeed been excluded from the compensation.

On Bladi.net : Moroccan farmworker awarded €238,000 after 712 days off work and five surgeries

The owner also wants the insurer to cover repairs to his garden, which he says was damaged when firefighters crossed it, as well as termite treatment. The invoices submitted for the garden refer, among other things, to pruning work, without establishing a connection to the emergency services’ intervention. As for the termites, the case file contains a 2011 inspection report confirming they were absent at the time, but no recent report documenting the claimed damage.

In its ruling issued on October 13, 2026, the Tarbes judicial court rejected all of the owner’s claims. He was ordered to pay the court costs, while each party was left to cover its other legal expenses.